The exhilarating and darkly comic musical “Teeth” has returned to New York’s off-Broadway scene, making a triumphant splash at New World Stages after its initial success earlier this year at Playwrights Horizons. Directed by the acclaimed Sarah Benson, “Teeth” transforms the 2007 cult horror film into a stage musical that’s equal parts gripping, hilarious, and shocking. With a larger, bolder production and an emphasis on the quirky and gory, Benson’s vision amplifies the daring themes and satirical humor that set the show apart.

Teeth Musical Premiere at New World Stages

The premiere night was as much about the show as it was about the buzz surrounding it. Attendees included prominent Broadway figures, actors, and influencers eager to witness the reinvention of a cult classic. The unique approach to horror and satire in a musical format generated much excitement among theater-goers, sparking social media conversations and praise. Fans were quick to share their reactions online, with hashtags like #TeethMusical trending shortly after the premiere. This enthusiasm speaks to the lasting impact of the production, which continues to captivate audiences with its audacious narrative.

One of the most notable aspects of the “Teeth” premiere was its set design. The production team transformed the typically modest space of New World Stages into an immersive environment that reflected the duality of Dawn’s journey. Starting with simple, wood-paneled walls that echo a church recreation room, the setting morphs dramatically as the story unfolds. This shift from familiarity to nightmarish surrealism mirrors the protagonist’s transformation and sets the tone for the audience’s experience.

Teeth Summary

At its core, “Teeth” tells the unique story of Dawn O’Keefe, a devout evangelical Christian teenager, who leads the Promise Keeper Girls—a church group dedicated to maintaining purity. However, Dawn’s life takes an unexpected turn when she discovers a bizarre and terrifying aspect of her anatomy: her vagina has developed sharp teeth. The storyline embarks on a journey of self-discovery and revenge, blending dark comedy with a horror-infused narrative, where Dawn uses her newfound power to confront the wrongs in her life. “Teeth” brings a refreshing twist to the stage, using biting satire, thought-provoking lyrics, and infectious melodies that address themes of sexuality, empowerment, and societal expectations.

Alyse Alan Louis shines in the role of Dawn, bringing depth and vulnerability to her portrayal of an innocent, devoted young girl who must grapple with extraordinary circumstances. As Dawn transitions from a naive leader of a purity group to a self-assured individual willing to confront oppression, Louis captures her character’s internal conflict and transformation with a dynamic range. Audiences are captivated by Dawn’s journey, which is infused with humor and genuine emotion, making her an unforgettable protagonist.

Jared Loftin as Tobey: Dawn’s loyal friend, Tobey is a complex figure who offers support yet grapples with his own insecurities and identity. Loftin’s portrayal of Tobey is poignant and adds layers of humor, especially as Tobey attempts to navigate his own challenges and contribute to Dawn’s journey. Andy Karl as Brad: Brad, Dawn’s rebellious stepbrother, is portrayed by Andy Karl, whose charisma and subtle menace add to Brad’s layered character. His interactions with Dawn are charged with tension, giving the show some of its most intense and memorable moments. Roe Hartrampf as Ryan: Ryan is initially charming but harbors darker motives. Hartrampf’s ability to portray Ryan’s hidden depths enhances the suspense, adding complexity to the storyline and making his character stand out.

Joanna Glushak as Kim: Dawn’s mother, Kim, provides moments of levity as a well-meaning yet oblivious parent. Glushak’s comedic timing and warm portrayal highlight the generational divide between mother and daughter. Teal Wicks as Dr. Godfrey: As a gynecologist who crosses paths with Dawn, Dr. Godfrey brings an element of discomfort and dark humor to the narrative. Wicks’s performance elevates the character’s creepiness, adding depth to the unsettling aspects of Dawn’s story.

Themes Explored in Teeth

Sexuality and Empowerment: By reimagining Dawn’s journey with humor and horror, “Teeth” explores the complexity of female empowerment and the societal taboos around sexuality. Dawn’s transition from innocence to self-assuredness symbolizes a reclaiming of her identity, challenging the expectations placed upon her by family, community, and religious doctrine.

Dark Humor and Satire: Humor plays a crucial role in the musical, allowing it to address difficult subjects with levity. From Dawn’s unexpected discovery to the satirical portrayal of purity culture, the musical balances light and dark, provoking laughter while encouraging reflection.

Generational and Ideological Gaps: The relationship between Dawn and her mother, Kim, serves as a backdrop for exploring the generational divide in views on purity and sexuality. This dynamic adds depth to the storyline, allowing audiences to see how different generations navigate societal expectations.

What can viewers expect from Teeth?

Teeth has managed to achieve something rare in musical theater: it combines humor, horror, and heartfelt moments to tackle complex themes in a way that feels both entertaining and thought-provoking. This latest staging at New World Stages is bigger and bolder, emphasizing the creativity of its cast and crew and Sarah Benson’s unique vision. For those seeking a unique theatrical experience that challenges conventions and sparks discussion, “Teeth” is an essential addition to their watchlist.